You asked:

I'm trying to find a dildo that's thicker than the standard size but not giant. I ordered a couple recently, and they ended up being way thinner than expected—like 1.5 inches thick, which is okay but not what I was hoping for. Every time I look, I only see these massive ones that are like 12 inches long and super wide. I really don’t need anything longer than 8 inches, just want something around 2 inches thick. Any suggestions?

Grace:

Right? It’s like they jump straight from “starter kit” to “industrial size”.

Thankfully, what you're after is out there, you just gotta dig a little. Based on everything you mentioned, I'd suggest the Tantus General. It’s 7 inches long with a max thickness of about 2.2 inches, and the shape makes it surprisingly easy to work with.